[CASL-L] Response to David - and something else Nutmeg

[Crean, Sue]

Thank you Kelly for your response. I do appreciate all the hard work of the
committee, and after I feel a little more settled in my position here, I
would like to participate.  I know from trying to pick books for a grades
5-8 middle school that it is difficult to find books that the students will
want to read that aren't beyond their maturity. Last year, my first in the
library, we promoted the Nutmegs and really enjoyed the selections of the
committee. We intend to do the same this year and I have thoroughly enjoyed
most of the ones I have read so far this year.
Thanks again,
Sue Crean

On Tue, Aug 25, 2015 at 8:34 AM, Williams, Linda <Linda.Williams at ct.gov>
wrote:

> I am forwarding this note from Kelley Gile, Chair of the Nutmeg Selection
> Committee that chose Reboot as a 2016 Teen Nominee in response to Sue
> Crean’s post to CASL (at the bottom of this email). I will be attempting to
> add resources to my page on Reboot as well, so watchi this space:
> https://ctbooksets.wordpress.com/2015/05/01/reboot/ ~ Linda Williams
>
>
>
> FROM KELLEY:
>
>
>
> "Thanks so much for your interest.
>
> Age-appropriateness is a matter of professional and personal opinion.  I
> had the honor and pleasure of working with 15 extremely dedicated
> individuals- six school librarians, six public librarians, and three
> students. We read 87 books in 9 months, and had a meeting every other month
> to discuss all the books we read. At the end, we narrowed down our choices
> to our top twenty books, and then had extensive discussions about balancing
> our final top ten list in terms of appropriateness, genres, reading levels,
> and student appeal. Choosing books for 7th and 8th graders can be a very
> challenging task- the kids almost always prefer to read about characters
> somewhat older than themselves, and are very leery of any book that seems
> too little kid-ish. The main focus of the Nutmeg books is to encourage
> children to read for enjoyment, so we did our best to choose quality books
> with a lot of appeal for 7th and 8th graders, and we had many, many
> discussions about the age appropriateness of most of the books we read.
>
> It was my committee's decision that "Reboot" was appropriate for 7th and
> 8th graders, and I wholeheartedly support them in this. As I've already
> mentioned, this is an opinion, and as everyone is entitled to their own
> opinion, of course you are more than welcome to disagree. There appears to
> be some disagreement even between professional journals, since SLJ lists
> the book at grades 7 and up, but Booklist rates it as appropriate for
> grades 8 - 12.
>
> I hope this helps, and I hope I've managed to explain the process to you-
> at least a little bit.  If you feel strongly about having your opinions
> heard about the age-appropriateness of any of the Nutmeg books, I would
> highly recommend to you to volunteer to be on one of the committees. It is
> a lot of work, but it is extremely satisfying and rewarding, knowing that
> you are utilizing one of your passions to enrich many, many children's
> lives. Thanks again for contacting me."
>
>
> It is a fact that SLJ lists the book at grades 7 and up, and Booklist
> rates it as appropriate for grades 8 - 12. I could go into detail about why
> the shower passages Ms. Crean included screen shots of are terribly
> important to the back story of why the main character feels non-human and
> how it adds to the poignancy of her eventual relationship. I could point
> out that at no time are there any descriptions of sex, the characters don't
> have sex or even approve of the sexual practices of their fellow reboots,
> and that the distinction is definitely made between love and sex... but I
> feel I shouldn't have to do that. People will always have their own
> opinions- that's what makes life interesting- and discourse should always
> be encouraged. However, it was my committee's professional opinion that the
> book was appropriate for 7th and 8th graders, and I totally support them...
> and I hope you will too.
>
> -Kelley
>
> Kelley Gile
> Teen Librarian
> Cheshire Public Library
>
> >
> >
> > Hi all,
> > I don't consider myself a prude, or ultra conservative, but I was a
> little shocked by Reboot (Nutmeg Teen Nominee) when the author described
> the showers as being used for sex - basically recreational since she made
> it clear that humans connect sex and love, but Reboots don't.  There are a
> few other mentions later in the book. I have no trouble with Wren and
> Callum kissing, but I felt that the description of the showers was really
> not necessary and offensive in a book for grades 7-8.
> > I have shown it to a few other people whose opinion I value and they
> agree this book is a better fit for high school.  I am having a rough time
> picking YA books for this age group. I believe that discussing sexuality is
> fine, and kids having relationships if done well and not graphically is
> fine. I think learning to navigate both an emotional and  physical
> relationship is important, and if done well (like FIOS, Laurie Halse
> Anderson, Sarah Dessen) is perfectly acceptable.
> > Thoughts?
> > Thanks,
> > Sue Crean
> >
> > --
> > Mrs. Sue Crean
> > Library Media Specialist
> > 21st Century Skills Teacher
> > Whisconier Middle School
> >
> >
>
>
>
> <image001.png>
>
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> CASL-L mailing list
> CASL-L at mylist.net
> http://mylist.net/listinfo/casl-l
>
>


-- 
Mrs. Sue Crean
Library Media Specialist
21st Century Skills Teacher
Whisconier Middle School
*“I’ve learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget
what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.” ~ Maya
Angelou*The information contained in this electronic mail message,
including any
attachments(s), is confidential information intended only for the use of
the individual or entity named above, and may be privileged.  The
information herein may also be protected by the Electric Communication
Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. Sections 2510-2521.  If the reader of this message
is not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any
dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly
prohibited.  If you have received this communication in error, please
notify the author by telephone at 203 *775-7616 *or by return e-mail, and
delete the original message. Thank you.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mylist.net/archives/casl-l/attachments/20150825/ef8a8fe3/attachment.html>